How to Select Wine Values by Points

I have made the point before about points,that is- points given to wines by the Wine Spectator as an example. And my point is you should definitely use points as a method to select wines, but do it wisely. Because in my humble estimation, a point is not necessarily a point.

I made this point first way back in 2015 in my blog entitled “How Much Is a Wine Point Worth.” I suggest you read it if you like saving money. In a nutshell, all you need do is divide the dollar cost of a wine by the point cost.

But now back to the article in Wine Spectator, which focused on California Pinot Noir. At the end of the article, WS provides a compendium of wine recommendations called an ‘Alphabetical Guide.” One listing caught my attention: Kirkland, which is the Costco label. I have been impressed by any wine I’ve picked up with the Kirkland label. And now I’m happy to see that 3 of their Pinot Noirs made the Guide: Carneros 2016 (88 points), Napa Valley Carneros 2017 (86 points), Russian River Valley 2017 (88 points).

The Kirkland Carneros at 88 points had the remarkably bargain price of $10. If you peruse the Guide for other wines with an 88 point rating, you’ll find, among others, the following: Iron Horse Russian River Valley 2016 Deer Gate $85; Joseph Jewell Halberg Vineyard 2015 $55; Longoria Sta. Rita Hills Fe Ciega 2016 $55; Luna Sta. Rita Hills Black Label 2016 $65; Macrostie Sonoma Coast Rodgers Creek 2016 $58; Peter Michael Santa Lucia Highlands le Moulin Rouge 2017 $110.

There were a number of 88 point rated wines in the $20/30 range but focus on that Peter Michael Pinot Noir at $110/bottle. Using my formula, each point for the Peter Michael costs you $1.25, whereas the Kirkland point sets you back a mere .11! I know some people have criticized my methodology, but I encourage all wine lovers to try a blind tasting. Take the Peter Michael and blind taste it against the Kirkland; they both received the same score from the WS. If you liked the Kirkland, you can buy almost 1 case for the price of one bottle of Peter Michael.

That’s my story and I rest my case.


Book this tour today! Book Tour


Sign up today for FREE and receive great wine recommendations, recipes and travel advice from wine educator, writer and radio host, Vin Marottoli - plus special savings offers on our tours.

No SPAM! Your information will not be shared or sold to third parties. You may unsubscribe any time.